• Question on an off-topic subject FM Radio, DAB+ or Manual HD Radio (IB

    From alisha@21:1/220 to All on Monday, May 10, 2021 18:01:41
    Hello all,

    What is the situation in your latitudes regarding FM, to what extent is HD radio based on IBOC an issue and what are your experiences with this type of reception?

    Currently there is a big discussion in Switzerland, our government has
    decided to switch off FM for commercial and non-commercial operation by the
    end of January 2023. In other words, anyone who wants to listen to the radio
    in the future will have to buy a DAB+-capable device or switch to other distribution channels (internet or DVB-C/S), depending on what the
    broadcaster offers.

    Personally, I am not a fan of DAB/DAB+, I prefer FM and was able to enjoy HD Radio (IBOC) during 2 years in the field test, which convinced me of this technology as a further approach to the FM frequency band. Unfortunately this technology is dead in Switzerland. I hope other countries have made a better decision here than Switzerland, which in effect orders the customer to enrich the entertainment industry by having to buy a new receiver. In my eyes, this
    is modern robbery of the taxpayer.

    Best regards

    Alisha

    --- Mystic BBS v1.12 A46 2020/08/26 (Linux/64)
    * Origin: swissIRC BBS (21:1/220)
  • From Nkeck72@21:3/122 to alisha on Tuesday, May 11, 2021 11:30:37
    In article <60995903.181.fsx_ham@finalzone.ddns.net>,
    "alisha" <alisha@21:1/220> wrote:

    Hello all,

    What is the situation in your latitudes regarding FM, to what extent is HD radio based on IBOC an issue and what are your experiences with this type of reception?

    Here in my neck of the US, analog FM is still going strong. There are a
    few stations nearby me with the digital sidebands common with HD radio
    over here (we don't have a digital system that outright replaces FM
    radio, rather the digital information is transmitted as two sidebands on either side of the analog carrier), though the number of digital
    stations is rather low here. I still listen to mainly analog FM during
    the day and analog AM for DXing at night.

    I've been hearing about European FM switchoffs for a few years now, and
    I'm sort of wondering what benefit, if any, it has. I've not really
    heard their reasoning for it over here in the states, and I'd be curious
    to know if you have the official reasoning for it.

    73, KN4YDZ
    --- SBBSecho 3.11-Win32
    * Origin: Final Zone BBS - finalzone.ddns.net (21:3/122)
  • From k9zw@21:1/224 to alisha on Monday, May 10, 2021 21:46:51
    No dab stateside (yet). I'm thinking we will have FM for some time to come. Still plenty of AM stations, as in certain areas FM doesn't carry far enough.


    Some DMR I'm told, but I live too rurally to see it.

    In our cars we are running SiriusXM, which is satellite subscription. Technically my sound system at home can stream the same service, but we
    almost never do so.

    Steve in Wisconsin

    What is the situation in your latitudes regarding FM, to what extent is
    HD radio based on IBOC an issue and what are your experiences with this type of reception?

    Currently there is a big discussion in Switzerland, our government has decided to switch off FM for commercial and non-commercial operation by the end of January 2023. In other words, anyone who wants to listen to
    the radio in the future will have to buy a DAB+-capable device or switch to other distribution channels (internet or DVB-C/S), depending on what the broadcaster offers.

    Personally, I am not a fan of DAB/DAB+, I prefer FM and was able to
    enjoy HD Radio (IBOC) during 2 years in the field test, which convinced
    me of this technology as a further approach to the FM frequency band. Unfortunately this technology is dead in Switzerland. I hope other countries have made a better decision here than Switzerland, which in effect orders the customer to enrich the entertainment industry by
    having to buy a new receiver. In my eyes, this is modern robbery of the taxpayer.

    Best regards

    Alisha

    --- Mystic BBS v1.12 A46 2020/08/26 (Windows/64)
    * Origin: SPOT BBS (21:1/224)
  • From Vk3jed@21:1/109 to alisha on Wednesday, May 12, 2021 21:28:00
    On 05-10-21 18:01, alisha wrote to All <=-

    Hello all,

    What is the situation in your latitudes regarding FM, to what extent is
    HD radio based on IBOC an issue and what are your experiences with this type of reception?

    In Australia, FM is still going gangbusters. DAB+ is available in the capital cities. There were rumours about DAB here, but I have never managed to receive any DAB+ signals on the receiver I have here. Certainly no plans to drop FM here that I'm aware of. AM is still quite functional here too, given the vast distances.



    ... Would you like to wake up from this dream?
    === MultiMail/Win v0.52
    --- SBBSecho 3.10-Linux
    * Origin: Freeway BBS Bendigo,Australia freeway.apana.org.au (21:1/109)